10 Screenwriting Mistakes Killing Your Script (And How to Fix Them)

You’ve spent months, maybe even years, pouring your heart and soul into crafting a screenplay you’re convinced is a surefire hit. But what if beneath the surface, lurk some critical screenwriting mistakes undermining your work? Failure to nail the fundamentals can render even the most promising premise or ingenious twist powerless to captivate audiences or industry readers.

Making these common screenwriting errors can derail your screenplay’s potential and prevent it from standing out in a fiercely competitive marketplace. To elevate your craft and increase your odds of success, it’s crucial to identify and avoid pitfalls that can sabotage your hard work. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore 10 prevalent screenwriting mistakes and provide actionable tips to steer clear of them.

Failing to Nail the Premise

A compelling premise is the bedrock upon which a great screenplay is built. It’s the central idea or concept that hooks the audience’s attention and intrigues them into wanting to know more. Without a clear, well-defined premise, your story risks lacking focus, direction, and emotional resonance.

Weak Premise: “A young woman moves to a big city to pursue her dreams.”

Strong Premise: “After losing her job and catching her boyfriend cheating on the same day, a quirky woman takes a chance and moves across the country to San Francisco in pursuit of her lifelong dream of becoming a chef.”

The second premise immediately sets up an inciting incident, introduces a goal with built-in obstacles, and hints at an intriguing, relatable character journey. Craft a premise that poses an inherently interesting scenario or question that will leave the audience eager to learn how it unfolds.

Underdeveloped Characters

No matter how high the stakes or intricate the plot, audiences connect with stories through characters they can invest in emotionally. One-dimensional, clichéd, or unrealistic characters are a surefire way to disengage viewers.

To bring your characters to life, develop multi-layered personalities with distinctive voices, behaviors, wants, flaws, and arcs of growth. Explore their backgrounds, motivations, and inner conflicts to make them feel authentically human.

For example, rather than a one-note “tough guy” protagonist, create a former military operative grappling with PTSD and a strained family relationship due to years of emotional unavailability. Such nuanced characterization immediately adds depth and fertile ground for meaningful storytelling.

Ineffective Structure

How you structure your narrative trajectory is paramount to maintaining audience engagement. Effective screenplay structure establishes clear acts, turning points, escalating obstacles, and moments of profound change for your protagonist.

Missteps like failing to properly set up key narrative pivots, neglecting act breaks that propel the story forward, or stretches of negligible plot progression can derail the audience’s experience. Your script’s backbone must be sturdy, purposeful, and drive the central conflict incessantly toward a climactic conclusion.

Familiarize yourself with proven structural principles like the Three-Act Structure, the Hero’s Journey, or the Sequential Outline to craft a solid narrative framework. Constantly ask yourself if each scene serves a clear, narratively crucial purpose. Eliminate excess that doesn’t drive the core story.

Awkward Dialogue

Clunky, artificial, or overly expository dialogue can pull audiences out of your narrative world faster than a meteor strike. Authentic dialogue is not only a hallmark of great screenwriting but absolutely vital to believability, immersion, and emotional truth.

If your characters sound like they’re delivering speeches in a void rather than having an actual conversation, you’ve got issues. Common dialogue pitfalls like being too “on-the-nose,” dropping unnatural exposition dumps, defaulting to clichés, or giving every character the same vocal patterns must be avoided.

The best dialogue should always reveal substance through subtext. Listen to how real people communicate – with verbal tics, interruptions, naturalistic cadences, and revealing character shades. Read your lines out loud to identify areas that feel stilted or unrealistic.

Inadequate Research and Preparation

You wouldn’t go skydiving without first learning how to safely operate a parachute. Similarly, diving headfirst into a screenplay without thorough research, planning, and outlining is a surefire way to end up with factual errors, logical inconsistencies, implausibilities, and unsatisfying payoffs.

Whether your story is a taut legal thriller where you’d better understand courtroom proceedings or a supernatural horror that needs to adhere to its own established rules of the metaphysical, do your homework. Exhaustively research relevant elements, locations, professions, conditions, etc., to ensure authenticity.

Devise a roadmap for how your story will unfold beat-by-beat, including character motivations, obstacles, turning points, and thematic exploration. An outline allows you to work through potential snags in your narrative architecture before committing words to the page. As the saying goes: “Plan ahead or pay the price.”

Clichés and Lack of Originality

In a world inundated with stories across mass media, recycling stale tropes and conventions is the surest path to having your screenplay feel derivative, uninspired, and disposable. Dare to be fresh, ask “What if?”, and find bold new angles to explore even the most well-trodden concepts.

Whether it’s another “amnesia who’s secretly a deadly assassin” spy thriller or a rom-com featuring the “quirky city girl torn between the hot jerky guy and mild-mannered nice guy,” predictable clichés will turn off discerning audiences and industry gatekeepers alike. Don’t let your hard work be dismissed as “been there, seen that.”

For potent originality, consider unexpected genre mash-ups, subversive character archetypes, unique narrative perspectives, unpredictable tonal shifts, and examining familiar subject matter through fresh cultural or philosophical lenses.

Ineffective Formatting and Presentation

Even the most scintillating, ingeniously structured, hot-off-the-pen screenplay can instantly lose credibility and impact due to poor formatting and presentation. In the movie industry, proper formatting etiquette is non-negotiable.

No, sloppy margins and page numbering, lack of spacing between elements, random hard returns, and typos may seem trivial. However, such technical sloppiness signals a lack of professionalism and disregard for industry norms. It distracts from the writing itself and plants seeds of doubt about the writer’s commitment and abilities.

Learn the accepted formatting rules for scripts. Indent properly, utilize clean font styles, use capitalization and spacing accurately, denote transitions in the correct manner, etc. Essentially, make your pages look and flow like the polished work of someone committed to the craft. First impressions matter.

Unclear Vision or Mixed Tones

Perhaps you’ve seen movies or shows that started off with a clear genre and tonal identity, only to veer jarringly in a different direction? It’s disorienting and disruptive when the audience is left uncertain about the very nature of the narrative experience you’re aiming for.

In the planning stages, you must establish an unwavering vision for what you want to create: is this a gritty crime thriller, quirky character dramedy, darkly comedic satire, or something else entirely? Define your core genre(s), consistent stylistic approach, and the overall mood you’re looking to evoke.

Once set, remain laser-focused on ensuring every narrative beat, thematic exploration, character dynamic, dialogue style, visual aesthetic, and storytelling device service and align with your vision’s cohesive tonal identity. Wildly erratic shifts will only throw your audience off the rails and dilute your work’s impact.

Failing to Follow “Show, Don’t Tell”

One of the fundamental tenets of compelling storytelling is the mantra “show, don’t tell.” Too often, screenwriters inadvertently fall into the trap of excessive exposition or blunt explanations instead of visually rendering key narrative information and emotional arcs for the audience to experience firsthand.

Simply stating “Joe was a jaded, cynical man” tells us the conclusion, but reveals neither the source of his cynicism nor allows us to see and feel that quality brought to life through his words, actions, private moments, etc. Exposition dumps stifle dramatic tension, audience discovery, and immersion.

Wherever possible, deploy vivid sensory details, subtext, revealing character behaviors, and visual storytelling to illustrate crucial plot points, thematic ideas, turning points, and transformations. Active dramatization shows the audience what’s happening rather than passively summarizing or telling them.

Neglecting Rewriting and Feedback

Even the most masterful writers know that a first draft is never truly done – it’s merely the initial iteration awaiting refinement. Far too many aspiring and even produced screenwriters bypass the indispensable rewriting and feedback processes that can elevate their material from good to great.

Rewriting with a critical eye allows you to fine-tune weaknesses, punch up dramatics, clarify ambiguities, and refine your story into its fullest, leanest, and most impactful form. However, it’s easy to remain trapped in your own creative perspective, missing flaws and opportunities for improvement lurking in the blind spots.

Seek out trusted sources to provide honest, constructive feedback throughout the writing process – workshop groups, experienced writers or consultants, or industry professionals. An outside perspective can reveal invaluable insights about what’s working, what’s falling flat, potential plot holes, character inconsistencies, and more.

Approach such input with an open, non-defensive mindset. You don’t have to incorporate every single suggestion, but carefully weigh the merits of each critique with the objectivity your screenplay deserves. Resist the urge to remain too precious over material that could benefit from additional finessing.

Conclusion – Screenwriting Mistakes

Avoiding these 10 prevalent mistakes can elevate your screenwriting from amateur hour to professional-grade work that resonates with audiences and impresses industry gatekeepers.

It’s a highly competitive arena, but sidestepping pitfalls like an unfocused premise, shallow characters, structural weaknesses, unrealistic dialogue, sloppy research, predictability, poor formatting, tonal confusion, lazy expository writing, and aversion to the rewriting process provide your unique voice and stories with their best chances of breaking through.

The path to success requires diligence, willingness to examine your blind spots, and a dedication to honing your craft relentlessly. While no screenplay is perfect, heeding these lessons will lead you away from fundamental missteps that have plagued many before you.

By establishing solid conceptual, plotting, character, and execution foundations from the onset, the world you’ve envisioned will be primed to transport readers into the depths of your imagination undisturbed. Master these fundamentals, and you’ll be well on your way to the screenwriting’s winner’s circle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the #1 rule when writing a screenplay?

The #1 rule of screenwriting is “show, don’t tell.” Great screenplays use vivid descriptions, actions, dialogue, and visuals to actively dramatize the story and characters rather than relying on exposition or telling the audience what’s happening. Showing brings the narrative to life and allows viewers to experience it firsthand.

What are the three C’s of screenwriting?

The three C’s of screenwriting refer to:

  1. Concept – Having a clear, compelling premise or story concept that hooks the audience.
  2. Character – Developing fully fleshed-out, multi-dimensional characters with authentic voices, behaviors, arcs, etc.
  3. Craft – Demonstrating mastery of screenwriting fundamentals like structure, formatting, dialogue, visual storytelling, etc.

What should a screenwriter avoid?

Some key things a screenwriter should avoid:

  • Clichés, predictable tropes, and lack of originality
  • Plot holes, inconsistencies, and logic gaps
  • Stilted, unrealistic, or overly expository dialogue
  • One-dimensional or archetypal characters without depth
  • Meandering scenes that don’t drive the narrative forward
  • Failing to properly format per industry standards

What is the 3 line rule in screenwriting?

The 3 line rule states that character descriptions in a screenplay should not exceed 3 lines of text. Anything longer than that is generally considered too lengthy and indulgent. Efficient, economical descriptions that crystallize key physical and personality traits are preferred.

What are the unwritten rules of screenwriting?

Some of the key “unwritten rules” of professional screenwriting include:

  • Never use camera directions/angles (leave that for the director)
  • Avoid writing unfilmable elements (dreams, fantasies, voiceovers, etc.)
  • Don’t stray from standard formatting and presentation
  • Limit examples of dialect, accents, or speech patterns
  • Craft stories with a maximum of 3-5 main characters
  • Stick to one genre rather than mixing multiple tones/styles

What is the hardest part of writing a screenplay?

Many professional screenwriters say the hardest part is nailing the structure and ensuring a tight, cohesive narrative with no lags, deviations or logic gaps from start to finish. Mapping out an airtight, compelling plot that builds properly is incredibly difficult. Other challenges include developing innovative high-concepts and creating authentic, memorable characters.

Is screenwriting a hard major?

Yes, screenwriting is considered one of the more difficult majors and fields to enter given the oversupply of aspiring screenwriters versus demand. Studying it intensively requires diligence, thick skin for relentless critique, and juggling both creative writing skills and technical mastery of screenplay formats. Breaking into the industry and selling scripts is extremely competitive.

What makes a well-written screenplay?

A well-written screenplay combines several key elements:

  • An original, high-concept premise that hooks you from page 1
  • Compelling, multi-layered characters you become invested in
  • A structure that creates escalating acts, obstacles and twists
  • Crackerjack dialogue that reveals character and story naturally
  • Visual storytelling and descriptions that immerse you in the world
  • Themes and character arcs that feel crafted and purposeful

What are the pillars of screenwriting?

The pillars or core fundamentals of quality screenwriting include:

  • Concept – Having a unique, compelling story premise
  • Structure – Mapping out an effective narrative architecture
  • Character – Developing authentic, memorable characters
  • Conflict – Instilling drama via incessant obstacles and tension
  • Dialogue – Crafting engaging, revelatory, and cinematic dialogue
  • Theme – Exploring substantive ideas and character arcs meaningfully
  • Visuals – Rendering vivid descriptions to immerse the audience

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *